Quality Street

At The New Vic, Newcastle-under-Lyme, until Sat 25 March

A tin of Quality Street comes in glittering colours but with few surprises. The play which gave the chocolates their name and since then has been rarely seen, on the other hand, comes as a huge surprise. It’s funny, dashingly romantic, and very sweet.

This theatrical rom-com by J M Barrie, who later wrote Peter Pan, touches on the same desire to remain young and free from adult responsibility. Its theme of women’s independence in a world dominated by men’s expectations is enriched by an inspired device. Co-producers Northern Broadsides, based in Halifax, have added commentary on the sexual mores of the time compared with today. It’s delivered by ‘staff’ from the Mackintosh chocolate factory, also in Halifax, as they change the set. It makes a delicious pairing.

Quality Street resident Phoebe Throstle eagerly awaits a visit from Doctor Brown, whom she had allowed to kiss her (“I wanted him to”).  She is expecting a proposal of marriage. Instead he announces with boyish enthusiasm that he has enlisted to fight Napoleon (“He is but half a man who stays at home”) and departs for ten long years.

Doctor Valentine Brown (Aron Julius) with housemaid Patty (Gilly Tompkins) Pics by Andrew Billington

Having lost the bulk of their incomes following bad investment advice from Brown, Phoebe and her older sister Susan set up a school. When the soldier returns expecting Phoebe to be unchanged he finds her instead run ragged by unruly pupils and just as unruly algebra. “He looks at me pityingly, seeing all my charm has gone and I have the headache,” she despairs. Within minutes her confidence turns as she tells Susan “I want to be bright and thoughtless and merry.” She lets down her curls and the goes to the victory ball after all – posing as her vivacious and vacuous niece.

Recruiting Sergeant (Jamie Smelt), Phoebe Throssel (Paula Lane) and Ensign Blades (Alex Moran)

The scene is set for fast paced ribald trickery as Phoebe and Susan are drawn ever further into the unforeseen consequences of their deception. It turns truly farcical as the tables are turned and the Captain, seeing the error of his ways, seizes his opportunity to put things right.  

Paula Lane as Phoebe switches effortlessly between the older and younger versions of herself. She gives a hilarious performance at the ball, enriching the dignity of a quadrille with thrusting teenage disco-dancefloor moves even as one of ‘Mac’s Lasses’ from the factory weaves in and out with a tin of chocolates. Louisa-May Parker’s Susan is the sweetest of old maids. The military men in their bright uniforms prove soft toffees with a nut at the centre.