At the New Vic Theatre, Newcastle-under-Lyme
It was an emotional evening at the New Vic — for Sally who found herself crying, though she couldn’t say why, as she watched old-timers stomping and gliding across a sweaty Cleethorpes dancefloor. And for plenty of old-timers in the audience who had the same experience watching twenty-something Sally.

It was proof that in his new play ‘Do I Love You?’ John Godber had found a winning device for indulging his lifelong passion for Northern Soul. The warm nostalgic response from his audience – many unable to resist clapping and singing along to snatches of favourite tunes – was validated by his three young characters discovering for themselves what it was all about. And it gave Godber a strong framework on which to hang his contemporary social commentary, insisting “It’s music for people who have nowt. Nowt’s changed since 1974.”

Sally (played by the author’s daughter Martha Godber), and her mates Natalie (Chloe Mcdonald) and Kyle (Emilio Encinoso-Gil) worked long hours taking orders at a drive-thru chicken joint. With late night buses home to a giant council estate, attacks by kids on E-scooters, and long waits in A&E, they lived directionless lives until they stumbled on the working-class phenomenon of Northern Soul.
Fascinated by the Frank Wilson’s cult song ‘Do I Love You?’, the fervour of the oldies still dancing the night away in northern clubs, and the stash of vinyl Sally inherited from her grandmother, the three eventually headed for the Tower Ballroom in Blackpool.
The performances were outstanding. Following a stream of introductory monologues, they delivered their terse dialogue with tight, upbeat energy which meshed perfectly with the music. So too did their physical expression and movement.

With choreographer Sally Molloy, who was herself crowned World Northern Soul Dance Champion in 2022, they gave a tantalising taste of the dance moves. But they also created beautiful visual shapes out of their triangular friendship – whether slumming on a beach, standing in a crowded bus, or calling out orders at work. Even when the three stumbled initially to imitate the moves of the old folks, it was clear that the spirit of the dance had infected them.
There was humour, sadness, and a touch of angst. But so cleverly did the whole come together that like Sally after five weeks listening to it nonstop, the rare souls in the audience who had never heard this music before “finally got what it was all about”.