New Vic Theatre, Newcastle under Lyme, until Sat 9 April
There’s a scene in Marvellous, the new play about the life of Neil Baldwin which has opened to packed houses at The New Vic, where the man who wrote the BBC award-winning drama of the same name, says: “I want it to be about community, inclusion, and optimism.” Assuming current Director and Dramatist Theresa Heskins had the same aims, she has pulled it off with knobs on. The extent to which she succeeds in making a moving night out at the theatre is a more open question.

Neil, or ‘Nello’ as he is widely known since his years as a circus clown, personifies community, inclusion, and optimism. He is much loved by many in the area which takes in the pot banks of the Five Towns, Keele University, Stoke City’s football ground, and the New Vic itself. His character is played centrally by Michael Hugo. The rest of the cast of six take the roles of many people in Nello’s life but also have turns as Neil himself.
The real Nello, now aged 76, has been closely involved in the development of the play and the narrative is clearly his. It’s presented workshop-style with Hugo’s Nello suggesting and interpreting as the others act out the scenes. It’s like looking through a big scrapbook. “I don’t mind being over committed,” Nello says. “I love doing things.” But amidst so many Nellos, both ordinary and extraordinary, I found the heart of the real Nello elusive.

Many of these episodes end with a simple statement of Nello’s boundless optimism. Welcoming new students to Keele University, unofficially, “It was marvellous.” Working away with the circus, his mum bought him a caravan, “And it was lovely.” Waiting in a downpour for Stoke City manager Lou Macari, who hired him as team mascot and kit man, “I got wet but it was great.” I had to take his word for it, rather than feeling it myself – though it’s an attitude which opened doors for Nello to meet Tony Benn, Prince Charles, the Archbishop of Canterbury and many many more.

In an early scene, a speech therapist talks about learning disability – a concept Nello has never had any truck with – and we see episodes of bullying at school and by footballers. But like Nello himself, who says “It was just a bit of fun”, the play goes for a laugh and quickly moves on.