At New Vic Theatre, Newcastle-under-Lyme, until Sat 19 April
A Matter of Life and Death opens with a brief reflection on the universe and our earthly place in it and instantly we know it means business. From start to well-deserved standing ovation at the end, the skills and creative talents awash in the New Vic’s toolbox combine to create theatrical magic.
Music, provided by an outstanding ten-piece swing band playing 1940’s classics, runs seamlessly through the earth-bound action so effectively it seems sprinkled on like stardust. It’s an inspired addition to her adaptation of the 1946 Powell and Pressburger film on the part of director Theresa Heskins. It never dominates the story yet it would provide an exhilarating evening’s entertainment on its own.

Squadron Leader Peter Carter is flying his damaged Lancaster bomber home on the last night of World War II. His distress call is answered by June at a US base on the English coast and their exchanges grow intense. ‘I’m baling out but there’s a catch. No parachute.’
Peter should have died but Conductor 71, the guide sent to conduct him to the other world, missed him in thick fog and before he can correct his error Peter has woken on the beach, met June cycling home, and fallen in love.

This setup is so sharp and to the point we barely have time to wonder how many layers of fantasy we have entered. Peter tells Conductor 71, ordered from above to fetch him, ‘I expected to die. It’s not my fault I didn’t, and then fell in love. Can I appeal?’ Meanwhile June’s friend Doc Reeves decides Peter is hallucinating because of a brain injury.
The climax is played out between two scenarios – brain surgery and a court hearing in heaven. So too are the substantial themes: ‘The law is the law’ and ‘Music, art, love, what else are we fighting for?’ while the band swings from ‘Boogie Woogie Bugle Boy’ to ‘Dream a Little Dream’.

Thomas Dennis and Kaylah Copeland play the lead roles with a mix of charm and earnestness which is ultimately deeply moving. Michael Hugo’s Conductor 71, guillotined in the French revolution, demonstrates his delight in technicolour earth with every delicately placed step and pursing of the lips. All three have their strong moments on the beautifully executed stairway to heaven.

Polly Lister lends an ever-optimistic benevolence to the role of Doc Reeves, even on her motorbike. Alexander Bean is the voice of a heavenly adjudicator personified. His final judgment brings spontaneous applause from the audience.
This review first appeared in the Market Drayton Advertiser